● A free public tool  ·  Built by Poptani Labs  ·  No sign-up  ·  Your data never leaves your browser
The Butterfly Effect · 5-minute read

The butterfly ballot: how a confusing ballot design decided a presidency

A ballot drop box outside a building in Sonoma, California
Image: 'Ballot box in Sonoma, California - November 2022 - Sarah Stierch 01.jpg' by Missvain, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

On the night of November 7, 2000, America went to bed not knowing who its next president would be. Three states were too close to call; Florida, with its 25 electoral votes, would decide it. When the counting finally stopped, George W. Bush led Al Gore in Florida by 537 votes out of nearly six million cast. And in one county, a piece of paper designed with the best of intentions had quietly moved several times that many votes to the wrong candidate. This is the story of the butterfly ballot — the layout error that may have decided a presidency.

A ballot redesigned to help

Palm Beach County, Florida, voted on punch cards in 2000. The county's Supervisor of Elections, Theresa LePore, had a problem: ten candidates were running for president, and listing them all on one side of the punch-card booklet would have meant tiny print. Palm Beach County has a large population of elderly voters, and LePore wanted the type big enough to read. So she spread the names across two facing pages, with the column of punch holes running down the middle like a spine. Voters were meant to follow an arrow from a candidate's name to the matching hole. It was, by every account, a well-intentioned fix — and it was used nowhere else in Florida.

The second hole belonged to someone else

Here is where the design broke. On the left page, George W. Bush headed the list and matched the first punch hole. Al Gore was second on the left — and the natural move was to punch the second hole. But the second hole belonged to Pat Buchanan, the Reform Party candidate, who headed the right page. Thousands of voters who meant to vote for Gore punched the second hole and voted for Buchanan instead. Others, sensing something was wrong, punched two holes — and had their ballots thrown out entirely. Palm Beach County discarded 19,120 presidential ballots punched for more than one candidate. The Palm Beach Post later found 5,330 voters who had punched both Gore and Buchanan, whose hole sat directly above Gore's on the card.

The numbers that didn't add up

Buchanan received 3,407 votes in Palm Beach County — 0.79 percent of the county's presidential vote, against 0.3 percent statewide. Statistical models built from the other 66 Florida counties predicted he should have drawn about 371 votes there. A study published in the American Political Science Review in December 2001, titled "The Butterfly Did It", concluded that more than 2,000 Democratic voters had voted for Buchanan by mistake. Buchanan's own campaign was startled: his sister and campaign manager, Bay Buchanan, told the Los Angeles Times two days after the election that she was surprised to hear claims of strong Reform support in the county — the campaign had bought no advertisements there and paid no visits. Bush's certified margin in Florida was 537 votes. The layout had moved nearly four times that number.

Chads, courts and consequences

The recount that followed introduced America to the vocabulary of punch cards: dangling chads, dimpled chads, hanging chads, pierced chads, pregnant chads and swinging chads — six ways a punch could fail to go all the way through. A circuit judge ruled on November 20 that no revote was legally possible in a presidential election. The Florida Supreme Court held that the ballot had not departed far enough from the statute book to void the election, and on December 12 the US Supreme Court stopped the recount in Bush v. Gore. The aftermath changed how America votes: the Help America Vote Act of 2002 pushed states toward new machines, and the punch card — and its chads — largely disappeared from American elections.

The Lesson

The butterfly ballot was not sabotage, and it was not a conspiracy. It was a readability fix, made by an elections official trying to help older voters, that broke the one rule every ballot must follow: the voter's intention must be obvious. A bigger font, a second page, an arrow pointing across a spine of holes — small choices, made with good intentions, that added up to a different president. Design, it turns out, is never just decoration.

Related on Poptani Labs: The missing hyphen that blew up a rocket to Venus, The officer who ignored five nuclear missiles — and saved the world, The wrong turn that started a world war: Sarajevo, 28 June 1914. More in this category: The Butterfly Effect.

Sources: Design Observer, the 2000 Palm Beach County ballot, Richard L. Smith, a statistical assessment of Buchanan's vote in Palm Beach County, Boles Blogs, Democracy Has a Layout

← All posts