● A free public tool  ·  Built by Poptani Labs  ·  No sign-up  ·  Your data never leaves your browser
Big Thinkers · 5-minute read

Emmy Noether: the woman who explained why energy is conserved — and wasn't allowed to teach

A page of Emmy Noether's handwritten table of invariants
Image: 'Emmy Noether - Table of invariants 1.jpg' by Emmy Noether, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Here is one of the deepest ideas in all of science, in a single sentence: every symmetry in nature corresponds to a conservation law. If the laws of physics work the same today as tomorrow, energy is conserved. If they work the same here as a metre to the left, momentum is conserved. Rotate the universe and you get angular momentum. Before 1918, conservation laws were observed facts — things physicists had noticed and trusted, without knowing why they had to be true. Emmy Noether showed why: they are consequences of symmetry, and her theorem became the organising principle of modern physics, from Einstein's relativity to the Standard Model. She proved it while not being allowed to teach under her own name, and without being paid. This is a research-based portrait, drawn from biographical and scientific sources — no new mathematics attempted, and the theorem stated in plain language, not in equations.

The problem Einstein couldn't solve

Noether's theorem came out of a specific problem. In 1915, Einstein's new general theory of relativity seemed to break the law of conservation of energy: as Einstein had presented his equations, the energy bookkeeping came out looking like a tautology — true, but telling you nothing. David Hilbert and Felix Klein, the two leading mathematicians at Göttingen, could not make the energy behave properly, so they invited Noether to Göttingen to help. She solved it, and in solving it produced a principle far larger than the problem: in any theory, if the laws stay the same over time, energy must be conserved — and the same logic, applied to other symmetries, gives the other conservation laws. Einstein was impressed enough to write to Hilbert about her paper on invariant forms. The paper itself was presented to the Göttingen scientific society by Klein — because Noether was not a member and could not present it herself.

Lectures under another man's name

Here is the fun anecdote — the four years Noether taught a university's courses without the university admitting she existed. When Hilbert and Klein brought her to Göttingen in 1915, the faculty blocked her habilitation, the qualification needed to lecture. One member protested, in the version of the story usually told: "What will our soldiers think when they return to the university and find that they are required to learn at the feet of a woman?" Hilbert, who had invited her, replied with withering contempt: "I do not see that the sex of the candidate is an argument against her admission. After all, we are a university, not a bathing establishment." The argument did not prevail. For four years her courses were advertised under Hilbert's name — students signed up for a Hilbert course and found Noether teaching it — and she was paid nothing. Her habilitation came in 1919; her first paid teaching position came in 1923, when she was forty-one. She never held a full professorship in Germany. She had already worked seven unpaid years at Erlangen, where she had studied as one of two women among nearly a thousand students, needing each professor's personal permission to attend his lectures.

Exile and the obituary

In 1933 the Nazis dismissed her for being Jewish, and she left Germany for Bryn Mawr College in Pennsylvania, where she taught for two years before dying in 1935, aged 53, after an operation. Einstein wrote her obituary in the New York Times, and his judgement has not been revised since: "In the judgment of the most competent living mathematicians, Fräulein Noether was the most significant creative mathematical genius thus far produced since the higher education of women began." The mathematician Hermann Weyl, who was given the professorship she deserved, said he was embarrassed to occupy a position she so clearly outranked him for. Her students, who called themselves the Noether Boys, followed her on walks through Göttingen arguing mathematics at full volume — and she was famously generous with her ideas, letting others publish results she had found.

The second theorem

Noether's theorem is the famous half of her legacy; the other half is just as large. Her 1921 paper on ideal theory is one of the founding documents of modern abstract algebra — the structures she defined are still called Noetherian in her honour, which is as close as mathematics gets to canonisation. And her theorem had a second part, less often mentioned, about a different kind of symmetry: it is the mathematical foundation of the gauge theories that became the Standard Model of particle physics. A century on, the theorem is still doing new work: physicists keep finding that the deepest descriptions of nature are descriptions of its symmetries, and every one of those descriptions runs through an idea proved in 1918 by a woman who was not allowed to lecture under her own name.

The Idea to Remember

The idea to remember is the theorem itself: the world is the way it is because of its symmetries, and every quantity that cannot be created or destroyed is a symmetry in disguise. Energy is conserved because tomorrow obeys the same laws as today. That is a beautiful fact — and it was proved by a mathematician who spent her career being told she did not belong in the room where it was proved. Noether's theorem survived its author, her century, and every institution that tried to keep her out of it.

Related on Poptani Labs: Alan Turing: the man who taught machines to think — and paid for being himself, Ada Lovelace: the woman who wrote the first program for a computer that didn't exist, Marie Curie: the notebooks too radioactive to touch. More in this category: Big Thinkers.

Sources: The 100-year-old symmetry theorem that is still changing physics today (New Scientist), Emmy Noether (1882–1935) — Unseen Genius, Emmy Noether: The Greatest Mathematician You Should Know About (Curio Infinity)

← All posts