● A free public tool  ·  Built by Poptani Labs  ·  No sign-up  ·  Your data never leaves your browser
What If? · 5-minute read

What would happen if the internet disappeared tomorrow?

Recovery of the HROV Ariane underwater vehicle aboard the research vessel Atalante at sea
Image: 'Récupération du HROV Ariane sur l'Atalante durant la campagne REDECOR' by Kim Dornic (IFREMER), CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Picture it: you wake up, reach for your phone, and nothing loads. Not slowly — not at all. No messages, no maps, no payments, no news.

First, the honest framing. There is no single switch for the internet: it is a network of networks, owned by thousands of companies. A total, permanent, worldwide disappearance is close to impossible. What can happen — and has happened — is that the connections between networks stop working: routes get withdrawn, cables get cut, or a government orders providers to go dark. This article is about that version. Evidence comes from real outages; the rest is labelled speculation.

The first hour: the quiet things stop first

You would notice your phone first. Messages would sit unsent, and chat, email, maps, and ride-hailing would fail together — underneath, they are all a request to a faraway server. (Speculation, but grounded: all need live connectivity.)

Money would be next. Card payments and UPI need a live network round-trip, so shops would fall back to cash — and cash only works until the ATMs run dry. One-time passwords would stop arriving, locking you out of even services still running.

What would not stop is just as telling: FM radio, landlines, and planes — air traffic control runs on radio and radar, not broadband — though booking and check-in would collapse into queues and whiteboards. The world would not end in the first hour. It would get slower, more local, and more confusing.

There is no single off switch — but there are chokepoints

Two pieces of plumbing explain why the internet can break without anything being "switched off." The first is BGP, the Border Gateway Protocol: the system by which networks announce, "here is how to reach me." Withdraw those announcements and a network vanishes from the map, unreachable though its computers are fine. The second is DNS, the phone book turning names into addresses. Break it and nobody can find anything, even with every cable intact.

Underneath both sits something physical and surprisingly fragile: the submarine cables on the ocean floor. More than 99% of intercontinental traffic travels through them, not satellites — over 500 cable systems spanning roughly 1.4 million kilometres, served by only about 60 repair ships, with 150 to 200 faults a year. Traffic reroutes around damage, so the system usually survives — but a handful of narrow straits carry a huge share of world traffic.

Sources: The Northern Voices on Europe's cable map, ITU submarine cable resilience reporting

We have already had previews — a country, and a company

The closest national preview happened in Egypt in January 2011. On 28 January, during protests against President Hosni Mubarak, providers were ordered to withdraw their routes. About 3,500 BGP routes vanished within hours, and roughly 88 to 93% of Egyptian networks became unreachable. The blackout lasted five days, until 2 February. One provider stayed online: Noor, which carried the Egyptian Stock Exchange. The OECD later put the economic loss at at least $90 million. People improvised: a French provider offered dial-up numbers anyone in Egypt could call, and Google and Twitter built "Speak to Tweet," turning voicemails into tweets.

The corporate preview came on 4 October 2021, when Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp disappeared for about six hours. The cause was not an attack but a faulty configuration change on backbone routers during maintenance, which disconnected Facebook's data centres; its DNS names stopped resolving and its BGP routes were withdrawn. Downdetector logged 10.6 million problem reports, a record for a single incident at the time.

Sources: Jigsaw, The Current: Internet Shutdowns, Access Now on Egypt's five-day shutdown, TechTarget on the 2021 Facebook outage

The anecdote that sticks: during the Facebook outage, reports said the company's own engineers struggled to enter their buildings — because the security badge system ran on the same network that was down. The outage did not just break the product; it locked the repair crew out of the repair shop.

Source: AlgoSec, reporting on the outage's internal impact

The money would stop before the food ran out

(Speculation, anchored to real estimates.) A Deloitte study commissioned by Facebook estimated that for a highly connected country, one day of complete shutdown costs about $23.6 million per 10 million people — roughly 1.9% of daily GDP. Scale that globally and the numbers stop being meaningful; the point is the direction. Modern economies keep no week's worth of cash and paper records as backup — payments, dispatch, ports, and markets all assume the network is there.

Physical goods would not vanish overnight — food in shops and warehouses stays put. But restocking is networked, and when scheduling software degrades, shelves empty unevenly over days. Egypt cuts both ways: five days offline cost at least $90 million, yet the country kept functioning, because the offline world — cash, markets, radio, feet — never went away.

Source: Deloitte, The Economic Impact of Disruptions to Internet Connectivity

What would survive

More than you might expect. Anything already on your device keeps working: downloaded maps, books, music, photos, and documents. Anything built to run locally keeps working too, which is why open-weight AI models that run on your own computer matter: unlike the cloud agents that passed the demo but live on remote servers, a local model does not care whether the internet exists. The week cloud agents went rogue was the other side of that coin: everything powerful and remote is also fragile and remote.

Beyond devices, the survivors are the older layers: radio, television, printed maps, landlines, and — as Egypt showed — dial-up modems and human messengers. The internet did not replace those layers; it buried them. A blackout would dig them back up within days.

The Bigger Question

The real question is not whether the internet can disappear. The previews say it can, locally and temporarily, and the mechanism is usually boring: a mistyped command, a withdrawn route, a badge reader on the wrong network. The real question is how much of life we have routed through a single point of failure — and what we could still do the morning after.

So try the inventory tonight: what on your phone works with Wi-Fi and mobile data off? What do you own that needs no server's permission? The answers are your answer to this article — and nobody can withdraw them.

More what-ifs in this series live on the What If? category page.

← All posts