Every year, thousands of highly paid fund managers try to beat the market. Every year, S&P Dow Jones Indices keeps score. The SPIVA scorecard — published twice a year since 2002 — lines active funds up against the index they claim to beat, and counts the dead funds too, so a closed fund can't quietly vanish from the record. The latest scorecards say the same thing they have said for two decades: most active funds lose, and the longer the horizon, the worse it gets. This is educational content, not investment advice — and every number below comes from the scorecard itself.
Over the 20 years to June 2026, about 93% of active US large-cap funds underperformed the S&P 500, according to the SPIVA U.S. Mid-Year 2026 scorecard. The year-end 2024 edition told the same story: 91.99% of large-cap funds trailed the index over 20 years, and across all active US domestic equity funds, 94.11% trailed the broader S&P Composite 1500. Over one year the picture is far kinder to active managers — in 2025, 79% of large-cap funds lagged the S&P 500, which still means one in five beat it. The pattern holds across categories: roughly 92% of mid-cap funds and 90% of small-cap funds trailed their benchmarks over 20 years. And most funds don't even survive that long: of the 2,373 US domestic equity funds alive in mid-2005, only 37.29% were still around twenty years later. The rest were merged or closed — usually after performing badly.
Two forces do the damage. The first is fees. An active fund charging 1% or more a year starts every year a full point behind an index fund charging a fraction of that, and the gap compounds — year after year, the active fund has to be not just good but good by more than its fee, just to tie. The second is survivorship: funds that do badly get merged or closed, so a simple average of the funds still standing flatters the industry. SPIVA counts closures as failures, which is why its long-horizon figures look so brutal. There is a fair counterpoint worth stating. A 2026 academic paper argued that SPIVA counts funds, not dollars — and asset-weighted, only about 55% of the money in active US equity funds underperformed over 20 years, because the biggest funds tend to do better than the smallest. The headline survives the caveat, but the honest version is narrower: picking a winning active fund is hard, and picking one that stays a winner is harder.
The most public test of the question came from Warren Buffett. In 2007 he bet $1 million that a low-cost S&P 500 index fund would beat a group of hedge funds over ten years. Ted Seides of Protégé Partners took the other side, picking five funds of funds that together held interests in more than 100 hedge funds. The hedge funds won the first year — 2008, when the index fund fell 37% — and then lost every year after. Final score, 2008 to 2017: the index fund gained 125.8%, about 8.5% a year, while the five hedge fund teams gained between 2.8% and 87.7%. The winnings went to Girls Inc. of Omaha — $2,222,279, more than double the original $1 million, after the stake was moved into Berkshire Hathaway shares in 2012. Buffett's own summary, from his 2017 letter to shareholders, is the whole argument in one line: "Performance comes, performance goes. Fees never falter."
None of this says active funds are useless, or that index funds always win — in any single year, a fifth to a third of active funds do beat the index, and some managers genuinely earn their fees for a while. It says the odds are against paying high fees for stock-picking, and they get worse the longer you hold. For most investors, the practical takeaway is boring and powerful: keep costs low, diversify, and let compounding do the work. If you do pay for active management, know exactly what edge you think you are buying — and check whether it survived the last ten years, not just the last one. The scorecard has been running for 25 years. It has not changed its mind yet.
The market is not a puzzle that rewards effort in proportion. Twenty years of scorecards say the average active fund loses to the index after fees, most funds don't survive twenty years, and even the best hedge funds in the world lost a public bet to a fund that does nothing at all. The cheapest edge in investing is the one you don't pay for.
Related on Poptani Labs: SIP vs lump sum: which is better for Indian investors?, The Rule of 72: the one division that tells you when your money doubles, Emergency funds: how much is enough, and where to keep it. More in this category: Money, Decoded.
Sources: LedgerTouch, SPIVA Scorecard: How Many Active Funds Beat the Index?, Walnut Invest, Active Fund Underperformance (SPIVA) Statistics, Stephen Loke, Buffett's Bet vs Hedge Funds, Nasdaq, Buffett Won His 10-Year Bet Against Hedge Funds
Don't just read about it — run the numbers on your own money with the same calculators this post draws on.