● A free public tool  ·  Built by Poptani Labs  ·  No sign-up  ·  Your data never leaves your browser
Money, Decoded · 5-minute read

The 4% rule: how much of your savings can you safely spend each year?

Exhibition panels about pensions at a visitor centre, showing pension charts and life-expectancy figures
Image: 'DNB visitor centre - ritirement pension' by Picasdre, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Every retirement plan eventually comes down to one question: I have this much saved — how much can I spend each year without running out? The most quoted answer in personal finance is the 4% rule. It is simple enough to fit on a sticky note, and it has an unusually solid origin: it came from a study, not a sales pitch. This is a research-based piece — the history of the rule and what the studies actually found — not personal financial advice.

The rule in one paragraph

Withdraw 4% of your portfolio in the first year of retirement. Every year after that, withdraw the same dollar amount, increased by inflation — regardless of what the market does. On a ₹1 crore portfolio, that is ₹4 lakh in year one; if inflation runs at 6%, year two is about ₹4.24 lakh, and so on. The flip side of the rule is the target it implies: if you can safely spend 4% a year, you need 25 times your annual spending saved before you retire (100 ÷ 4 = 25). Spend ₹6 lakh a year and you need ₹1.5 crore. Two details get lost in the shorthand. First, 4% is the first-year rate only — you do not recalculate 4% of the balance every year. Second, the rule assumes you stay invested in a balanced portfolio of stocks and bonds through downturns, not parked in cash.

The rocket scientist who found it

The rule was not invented by a bank or a fund salesman. It came from William Bengen, a financial planner who had studied aeronautics and astronautics at MIT. In October 1994 he published a 10-page paper, Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data, in the Journal of Financial Planning. He took actual US stock and bond returns going back to 1926, built a 50% stock / 50% bond portfolio, and tested what happened to a retiree starting in every single year from 1926 to 1976, withdrawing between 3% and 10% a year. The worst case in his data was someone who retired in 1966 — walking straight into a decade of stagflation and some of the poorest real stock returns in US history. Even that retiree, withdrawing 4% a year adjusted for inflation, had money for at least 33 years. In Bengen's own words: "In no past case has it caused a portfolio to be exhausted before 33 years, and in most cases it will lead to portfolio lives of 50 years or longer." He wasn't trying to start a movement. He was answering a question his clients kept asking — and the answer, rounded down from about 4.15%, became the 4% rule.

The Trinity study made it famous

Four years later, three finance professors at Trinity University — Philip Cooley, Carl Hubbard and Daniel Walz — tested the idea differently. Instead of looking only for the worst case, they asked how often a given withdrawal rate survived 30 years across all of history. Their 1998 paper, published in the AAII Journal, became known as the Trinity Study, and it is the paper most people actually mean when they cite the 4% rule today. Their finding: a 4% initial withdrawal, raised with inflation each year, succeeded in about 95% of historical 30-year periods for balanced portfolios. The study also showed how fast the odds fall once you go above 4%. With a 50/50 portfolio, a 4% start survived 95% of all 30-year periods. At 6%, it was close to a coin toss. At 8%, it failed 9 times out of 10. The real lesson of the Trinity Study isn't that 4% is magic — it's that 7% or 8% a year has a long history of ending in disaster.

Even Bengen changed his mind

Here is the part most retellings leave out: Bengen himself no longer says 4%. In a 2006 update, after adding small-cap stocks to the portfolio mix, he revised his recommendation upward to about 4.5%. In a December 2025 interview he put his updated figure at 4.7%. Meanwhile Morningstar's 2026 analysis, using Monte Carlo simulation rather than history, puts the safe starting rate at 3.9%. So the honest range from the people who study this for a living is roughly 3.9% to 4.7% — and your own number depends on how long you need the money to last, your fees, and how flexible you can be about spending in bad years. A retiree who can cut spending when markets fall can safely start higher than one who cannot.

What it means in India

One warning matters more than any other for readers here: Bengen and Trinity used US stocks and bonds, and US inflation. Indian markets have a different history, Indian inflation has run higher, and the rupee's purchasing power behaves differently. The 4% figure is a starting framework, not a prescription — and it ignores taxes and fees entirely. That is why a withdrawal rate should be tested against your own numbers, not copied from an American paper. Our SWP Simulator lets you do exactly that: pick your corpus, your monthly withdrawal, and see how long the money lasts across real historical returns. Run the numbers on your own money before trusting any rule of thumb — including this one.

Disclaimer: Educational summaries only — not financial advice. The 4% rule is a historical rule of thumb from US market data; it is not a guarantee, and your safe withdrawal rate depends on your own portfolio, taxes, fees and spending flexibility. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks.

The Takeaway

The 4% rule is best read as a target, not a law: save 25 times your annual spending, and you have a historically strong chance of never running out. The number itself matters less than the discipline behind it — spend a fixed real amount, stay invested through bad years, and check the maths against your own life, not someone else's history.

Related on Poptani Labs: The Rule of 72: the one division that tells you when your money doubles, Index funds vs active funds: what 20 years of SPIVA data actually says, Emergency funds: how much is enough, and where to keep it. More in this category: Money, Decoded.

Sources: PlanMyFIRE, The 4% Rule: The Simple Formula That Changed Retirement Planning, WinPie, The 4% Rule: Trinity Study Origins, RecaTools, The 4% Rule Explained: Bengen, Trinity & 2026 Updates, Stephen Loke, 4% Rule Explained: Will Your Money Last in Retirement?

Try the interactive tool

Don't just read about it — run the numbers on your own money with the same calculators this post draws on.

← All posts