In May 2023, former Apple designer Imran Chaudhri walked onto a TED stage and showed the future: a small square pin, worn on your chest, with no screen at all. It would answer questions, make calls, translate languages, and project a tiny interface onto your palm with a laser. The pitch was seductive — a computer that lets you look up from your phone. The Humane Ai Pin launched in April 2024 at $699, plus a mandatory $24-a-month subscription. Ten months later, the company sold its assets to HP for $116 million, and every Ai Pin in the world stopped working. This is a research-based piece — the documented rise and fall of a product, not a hands-on review.
The verdict arrived fast, and it was nearly unanimous. Tech reviewer Marques Brownlee headlined his review "The Worst Product I've Ever Reviewed… for Now" and called the pin "bad at almost everything it does basically all the time." Engadget's Cherlynn Low called it "futuristic for sure, if the future sucked." The Verge's David Pierce wrote bluntly that "the pin is not worth the money, not yet and probably not any time soon." The complaints were specific, not vague: answers took seconds to arrive from the cloud, the device overheated and shut down, the battery lasted hours not days, and the laser-projected palm display was unreadable in sunlight. A $699 device with a $24 monthly fee was doing less than the phone in your pocket — slower, hotter, and with no screen to fall back on.
Humane had planned to sell 100,000 pins in its first year. It shipped about 10,000. Then the returns started. According to internal sales data obtained by The Verge, between May and August 2024 more Ai Pins were returned than sold — by August, only around 7,000 units were still in customers' hands, against more than $1 million worth of returns. The returned units couldn't even be refurbished and resold: the pin's cellular connection was tied to its original owner through a T-Mobile deal, so a returned pin could never be reassigned to a new customer. They became e-waste. Total lifetime sales came to just over $9 million. And in May 2024, Humane asked customers to stop using the Ai Pin's charging case because its battery posed a fire risk — the case was later formally recalled. Bloomberg reported that same month that Humane was seeking a buyer at $750 million to $1 billion. It had raised more than $230 million from investors including OpenAI's Sam Altman.
On February 18, 2025, HP announced it had agreed to acquire Humane's key AI assets — the Cosmos AI platform, its engineers, and more than 300 patents and patent applications — for $116 million. The engineers would form a new HP group called HP IQ. The Ai Pin itself was not part of the deal. The same day, Humane told customers it was winding down the consumer Ai Pin, effective immediately. Pins would "continue to function normally until 12pm PST on February 28, 2025" — ten days later. After that, they would no longer connect to Humane's servers, which meant no calling, no messaging, no AI answers, no cloud access, and all remaining consumer data permanently deleted. The devices didn't break. They just stopped — a $699 pin reduced to showing its battery level. The company that had asked buyers to look up from their phones had switched its own product off.
The Ai Pin is the clearest warning yet about cloud-dependent hardware: when a gadget's brain lives on someone else's server, you are renting its function, not buying it. The pin's useful life was set by a business decision, not by the hardware wearing out. The contrast is its contemporary, the Rabbit R1 — a $199 AI gadget launched weeks after the Pin, which is still on sale and still receiving software updates. The Pin's failure wasn't that the idea was wrong. Wanting less screen time is a real desire, and a voice-first wearable is a real idea. The failure was execution: a first product that tried to replace the phone instead of complementing it, priced like a flagship, dependent on a subscription, and slower than the thing it was replacing.
The Humane Ai Pin raised over $230 million, sold about 10,000 units, and was switched off ten months after launch. The lesson is not that ambitious hardware always fails — it is that a gadget which needs a server to think can be unplugged by a press release. Before buying any device that does its thinking in someone else's cloud, ask what happens to it the day that cloud goes away.
Related on Poptani Labs: Are VPNs worth it? What they actually do — and what they don't, Blue-light glasses: what the trials actually say (and what helps instead), Why AI can't count the R's in 'strawberry' — and what that tells you. More in this category: Beyond the Hype.
Sources: HeyTalaya, What happened to the Humane AI Pin and Rabbit R1 (2026), The Internet Ninja, Humane discontinued the Ai Pin; HP bought its AI assets for $116M, AIVAnet, People are returning the Humane AI Pin more than they're buying it, EuropeanTech, How the Humane AI Pin Flopped